Who is the liar?

[Locke]

Ok, lets try to figure this out :

--------------------------------

Person 1:
''Person 2 is a liar.''

Person 2:
''Person 3 is a liar.''

Person 3:
''Both Person 1 and Person 2 are telling the truth.''

Who is the liar?

--------------------------------------------

Pretty simple...., isnt it lol

[Goldie-2012]

Person 2 and 3 :huh:

[Robot's_Best_Friend]

What goldie said....lol

[InterstellarPicnic]

Ok, lets try to figure this out :

--------------------------------

Person 1:
''Person 2 is a liar.''

Person 2:
''Person 3 is a liar.''

Person 3:
''Both Person 1 and Person 2 are telling the truth.''

Who is the liar?

--------------------------------------------

Pretty simple...., isnt it lol

You brained my damage O_o

[Teesside Native]

Person 1 and 2

[EdgeCrusher]

.....everyone?

[SiCofReality]

Ok, lets try to figure this out :

--------------------------------

Person 1:
''Person 2 is a liar.''

Person 2:
''Person 3 is a liar.''

Person 3:
''Both Person 1 and Person 2 are telling the truth.''

Who is the liar?

--------------------------------------------

Pretty simple...., isnt it lol

Well if person 1 isnt being called a liar, but 2 is lying about 3, but 3 says 2 is telling the truth then 1 is really the only one who isn't confusing me at this point because he hasn't been called a liar but if 3 is lying then how do we know its not the opposite and he's calling 1 a liar.


I need these guys in the interrogation room immediately.

[Hussypuff]

1 is apparently telling the truth... And Person 3 says 1 and 2 are telling the truth, but if he's lying then 1 and 2 are liars, if not, 1 and 2 are not liars. If person 1 says 2 is a liar, then person 3 is NOT a liar O_o... Oh good god LOL.

[I Hate Bottles]

What is this? I don't even...

[Hussypuff]

Yeah... my head pretty much exploded.... lol

[SiCofReality]

I haven't slept in 3 days because of this thread!!
WHO'S THE LIAR!?! THEY'RE ALL LYING!! ALL OF THEM! AND THERE'S ONLY ONE WAY TO TAKE CARE OF THIS!!!

MEET MAH LIL FREHEND!
http://www.underconsideration.com/random/maven_cat.gif

[Yoshirama]

locke please give them the answer.

[Locke]

I dont even know it myself lol